This report describes a direct assessment activity within the IU Indianapolis Institute for Engaged Learning (IEL) for students participating in IEL programs during AY 2023-2024. The IEL Assessment Workgroup assessed written reflection artifacts of 80 students from 6 co-curricular programs. Using selected rows from the Integrative Learning, Civic Engagement, and Problem Solving AAC&U VALUE Rubrics, the raters assessed the Community Contributor, Problem Solver, and Innovator Profiles of Learning for Undergraduate Success.