Discharges against medical advice: time to take another look. A retrospective review of discharges against medical advice focused on prevention

Abstract

Background Discharges against medical advice (DAMA) increase the risk of death. Methods We retrieved DAMA from five hospitals within a large health system and reviewed 10% of DAMA from the academic site between 2016 and 2021. Results DAMA increased at the onset of the pandemic. Patients who discharged AMA multiple times accounted for a third of all DAMA. Detailed review was completed for 278 patients who discharged AMA from the academic site. In this sample, women comprised 52% of those who discharged AMA multiple times. Relative to the proportion of all discharges from the academic site during the study period, Black patients were overrepresented among DAMA (21% vs. 34%, p < .05). Patients with multiple AMA discharges were younger, more likely to be unmarried, or have substance use disorders (SUD) than those who discharged AMA once. The most common reason for requesting premature discharge noted in n = 77, 28% of instances was related to patient obligations outside the hospital. Hospital policies and procedures contributed in n = 29, 10% of instances. Reasons for requesting premature discharge and documentation of key safety processes were similar by gender and race however the sample may be underpowered to detect differences. Capacity was evaluated in 109 (39%). Among those who consumed alcohol (n = 81 (29%)) or had SUDs (n = 112 (40%)), information on the amount or timing of last use was missing in n = 39 (48%) and n = 74 (66%), respectively. Critical tools to manage illness were provided in 45 (16%) of DAMA reviewed. Conclusions Drivers of AMA discharge may differ by AMA discharge frequency. Recognition of the common reasons for requesting premature discharge may help destigmatize AMA discharges and also identifies early assessments by social work colleagues as an important prevention strategy. Opportunities also exist in anticipating and preventing withdrawal symptoms and in revising hospital practices that contribute to DAMA.