Should Supreme Court Justices Fear Access to Their Papers? An Empirical Study of the Use of Three Archival Collections

If you need an accessible version of this item, please submit a remediation request.
Date
2022
Language
American English
Embargo Lift Date
Department
Committee Members
Degree
Degree Year
Department
Grantor
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Found At
Abstract

US. Supreme Court justices typically donate their working papers to archives upon their retirement, often with lengthy embargoes. Researchers have debated whether the justices should be required to retain and disclose their papers as government records, but there has been little study of how the papers are used in scholarly and journalistic discussions of the Court. This empirical study examines how the papers of Justices William Brennan, Thurgood Marshall, and Harry Blackmun are used via citations in books and academic law journal articles. We find that most citations to the papers support discussions of the justices' views on the law along with deliberations and negotiations when deciding cases, precisely the kinds of uses that show the value of transparency. To address constitutional objections to mandated disclosures, we propose an incentive grant program that benefits the archives receiving justices' collections. This program would encourage justices to donate their papers with relatively short embargoes, ideally fifteen years after retirement from the Court.

Description
item.page.description.tableofcontents
item.page.relation.haspart
Cite As
Susan David deMaine and Benjamin J. Keele, Should Supreme Court Justices Fear Access to Their Papers? An Empirical Study of the Use of Three Archival Collections, in The Role of Citation in Law: A Yale Law School Symposium (Michael Chiorazzi, ed., 2022)
ISSN
Publisher
Series/Report
Sponsorship
Major
Extent
Identifier
Relation
Journal
Source
Alternative Title
Type
Book chapter
Number
Volume
Conference Dates
Conference Host
Conference Location
Conference Name
Conference Panel
Conference Secretariat Location
Version
Full Text Available at
This item is under embargo {{howLong}}