Bayesian design and analysis of cluster randomized trials

Abstract

Cluster randomization is frequently used in clinical trials for convenience of inter ventional implementation and for reducing the risk of contamination. The opera tional convenience of cluster randomized trials, however, is gained at the expense of reduced analytical power. Compared to individually randomized studies, cluster randomized trials often have a much-reduced power. In this dissertation, I consider ways of enhancing analytical power with historical trial data. Specifically, I introduce a hierarchical Bayesian model that is designed to incorporate available information from previous trials of the same or similar interventions. Operationally, the amount of information gained from the previous trials is determined by a Kullback-Leibler divergence measure that quantifies the similarity, or lack thereof, between the histor ical and current trial data. More weight is given to the historical data if they more closely resemble the current trial data. Along this line, I examine the Type I error rates and analytical power associated with the proposed method, in comparison with the existing methods without utilizing the ancillary historical information. Similarly, to design a cluster randomized trial, one could estimate the power by simulating trial data and comparing them with the historical data from the published studies. Data analytical and power simulation methods are developed for more general situations of cluster randomized trials, with multiple arms and multiple types of data following the exponential family of distributions. An R package is developed for practical use of the methods in data analysis and trial design.