The FDA’s Graphic Tobacco Warnings and the First Amendment

If you need an accessible version of this item, please email your request to digschol@iu.edu so that they may create one and provide it to you.
Date
2013
Language
English
Embargo Lift Date
10000-01-01
Department
Committee Members
Degree
Degree Year
Department
Grantor
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Found At
Abstract

In the past, the government enjoyed broad authority to regulate tobacco or pharmaceutical advertising. Protection for commercial speech was weak, and state power to protect the public health was strong.

But the U.S. Supreme Court has changed course. Corporate speech rights have become robust, and the justices exhibit less deference when the state exercises its public health authority. As a result, government is much more susceptible to challenge when it tries to regulate the promotional activities of cigarette manufacturers or pharmaceutical companies.

This "Perspective" piece illustrates the evolution of First Amendment doctrine for public health regulations with a discussion of the Food and Drug Administration's graphic warnings for cigarette packages. Even though textual warnings for cigarettes have been upheld, and even though the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit recognized a role for some color image warnings, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit rejected the FDA's actual graphic warnings (which were developed pursuant to a graphic warnings mandate from Congress).

Rather than seek Supreme Court review, the FDA decided to revise its graphic warnings. In the meantime, we are left with some important questions about the factors that distinguish between permissible and impermissible graphic warnings.

Description
item.page.description.tableofcontents
item.page.relation.haspart
Cite As
David Orentlicher, The FDA's Graphic Tobacco Warnings and the First Amendment, New England Journal of Medicine 369:3, 204-206 (2013). doi: 10.1056/NEJMp1304513
ISSN
Publisher
Series/Report
Sponsorship
Major
Extent
Identifier
Relation
Journal
Source
Alternative Title
Type
Article
Number
Volume
Conference Dates
Conference Host
Conference Location
Conference Name
Conference Panel
Conference Secretariat Location
Version
This item is under embargo {{howLong}}
forever