Browsing by Subject "dissent from the bench"

Now showing 1 - 1 of 1
  • Thumbnail Image
    Item
    “The Brooding Spirit of the Law”: Supreme Court Justices Reading Dissents from the Bench
    (2010-01) Blake, William D; Hacker, Hans J
    In rare instances, a Supreme Court justice may elect to call attention to his or her displeasure with a majority decision by reading a dissenting opinion from the bench. We document this phenomenon by constructing a data set from audio files of Court proceedings and news accounts. We then test a model explaining why justices use this practice selectively by analyzing ideological, strategic, and institutional variables. Judicial review, formal alteration of precedent, size of majority coalition, and issue area influence this behavior. Ideological distance between the dissenter and majority opinion writer produces a counterintuitive relationship. We suspect that reading a dissent is an action selectively undertaken when bargaining and accommodation among ideologically proximate justices has broken down irreparably.